Amanda Orneck liked the forum thread, Commenting and Critiquing Etiquette
Scathing critiques say more about the one giving the criticism than the work being criticized I believe.  I have been on the receiving end of that too many times myself and it is not helpful in the least.
like · liked by A. and 2 others

People who have liked this comment in the forum thread, Commenting and Critiquing Etiquette

    Amanda Orneck followed Wesley Earl Jack Reid
    Wesley Reid
    A lover of words and aspiring author with a dream of turning traditional fantasy on its head.
    Follow
    Wesley Reid followed Amanda Orneck
    Amanda Orneck
    Author of Sister of the Circuit, Shadow of the Owl, and a recipe for a pretty decent mushroom fritta...
    Follow
    Amanda Orneck liked the forum thread, Commenting and Critiquing Etiquette
    Part of it depends on the author, I think, but as a general rule it seems preferred that critiques be done privately. This is especially true for excerpts currently in the funding phase, since negative comments (however constructive) draw attention to issues both real and perceived, and affect how visitors view the project. I’d like to say that anything goes for a project that’s still in the draft stage, since that stage is supposedly for people to perfect their project pitch, but there again, it’s always best to be constructive.
    like · liked by Darcy and 6 others

    People who have liked this comment in the forum thread, Commenting and Critiquing Etiquette

      Amanda Orneck liked an update for Are You Sure You Want to Quit?

      Good morning!! As I promised, here is the first piece of the painting! The subsequent pieces will be revealed every 25 pre-orders from here on out :) And thanks to all of you I’m currently in 3rd place in the contest! I want to ride this momentum and push myself to write even harder this weekend :)

      like · liked by Whoa and 5 others

      People who have liked this reader update

        Amanda Orneck followed Ingrid Emerick
        Ingrid Emerick
        Editor at Girl Friday
        Follow
        Amanda Orneck liked an update for Orin and the Skyscrapers

        Hey everybody! So as some of you know, I’m a first year teacher and I’m just starting to enjoy the number one perk of the job in my opinion...SUMMER VACATION! It was a great end to a great school year and I’m anxious to get this book all wrapped up and into your hands. I still lack about 100 issues to meet my "Quill" publishing goal, but I’m confident that with a little marketing and enthusiasm it will come. Thanks everyone for hanging in there and being patient. 

        All the best,

        J.H.Trevino

        like · liked by Amanda and 1 other

        People who have liked this reader update

          Amanda Orneck followed Ryan Muzzey
          Ryan Muzzey
          I am a Software Development Engineer for Woot.com living in the Seattle area. When I’m not writing c...
          Follow
          Amanda Orneck liked an update for The Punch Escrow

          Happy Saturday to the loveliest readers in the world. There have been some amazing developments that I am finally able to share with you. It’s been hard holding it in, but now that it’s official I’m happy to announce that I will be writing a column called The Future is Now that will explore the intersection of science fiction and present technology. The first TFIN, in which I explore the current state of laser weaponry is now live!

          You’ll be pleased to know that debate over my flagrant reference to lasers and phasers being "the same thing" has already incited a heated debate among the Trekkies of Geek & Sundry, and so, in traditional fashion, I have managed to outraged the very people I was trying to entertain.

          Speaking of outrage(!) - The future vintage International Transport shirts have arrived. These beautiful organic cotton shirts commemorate and celebrate International Transport’s 2393 R&D Offsite during which The Punch Escrow was first successfully tested in the teleportation of a live human "volunteer".

          This means that the logistics of shipping all of the good stuff many of you have earned or won will likely happen in the next week. I have gotten a lot of requests to buy the shirts, but unfortunately I’m just not set up to sell them. Likely Geek & Sundry will probably take over merchandising for The Punch Escrow as we get closer to the publication date. Maybe they will resurrect this design. As things firm up I will let you know where to go/who to ask to make these kind of requests.

          Lastly, the amazing anthology of which I am a part, Too Many Controllers, continues to go from strength to strength in the Nerdist "video game" contest. We’ve already reached "Quill" publishing status, meaning that regardless of whether we win the contest or not, our anthology is getting published, but we’re in it to win it, my friends. I was hoping to share the synopsis of my story with you, but alas, we have a strict information release cadence. I’m told that perhaps my story’s synopsis will be unveiled once our reader count reaches 300. Please help us get there! Here is a "hint":


          like · liked by Kevinwsatterly and 9 others

          People who have liked this reader update

            Erin S. Evan followed Amanda Orneck
            Amanda Orneck
            Author of Sister of the Circuit, Shadow of the Owl, and a recipe for a pretty decent mushroom fritta...
            Follow
            More items