Sam Fellows commented on an excerpt of Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai
Thanks - see my response to your comment at the end of this chapter.
like

People who have liked this comment on a chapter of <i>Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai</i>

    Sam Fellows commented on an excerpt of Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai
    There’s a clear theme to a number of your comments, and - genuinely without wishing to be facetious - are you familiar with epic fantasy series like Steven Erikson’s Malazan Book of the Fallen or Robert Jordan’s Wheel of Time? This type of series has a cast of dozens, if not hundreds of point-of-view characters - the idea of a single "main" character isn’t really how they work. As a result, the build-up of plot takes a lot longer as there is a much larger cast to introduce, and far more world-building to establish.

    Bear in mind that the scale of these novels is exponentially larger than a 300-page standalone book; the full series will likely be closer to ten times that length. I wonder if perhaps you were expecting the book to be something that it isn’t. I don’t wish to dismiss your concerns - some of them are certainly spot-on - but while certain aspects are changeable, the overall scope and genre are not.
    like

    People who have liked this comment on a chapter of <i>Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai</i>

      Sam Fellows commented on an excerpt of Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai
      Thank you!
      like

      People who have liked this comment on a chapter of <i>Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai</i>

        Sam Fellows commented on an excerpt of Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai
        It is a race name - but race names aren’t proper nouns. You wouldn’t capitalise "human", would you? "Vaivardi" isn’t a nationality, but the name of a species.
        like

        People who have liked this comment on a chapter of <i>Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai</i>

          Sam Fellows commented on an excerpt of Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai
          Thank you. Bear in mind this is just the prologue, though - by definition, it’s separate from the main story. It’s designed to inspire a bit of mystery and pique interest. It absolutely is not designed to introduce any main characters - if the prologue were focused on the main characters, then I’d argue it wouldn’t be a prologue!
          like

          People who have liked this comment on a chapter of <i>Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai</i>

            Sam Fellows commented on an excerpt of Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai
            Absolutely - by design, not by mistake. It’s repeated for emphasis - it’s the theme of this passage.
            like

            People who have liked this comment on a chapter of <i>Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai</i>

              Sam Fellows commented on an excerpt of Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai
              No, far from it.
              like

              People who have liked this comment on a chapter of <i>Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai</i>

                Sam Fellows commented on an excerpt of Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai
                I’ve been deliberating over this one - you’re not the first person to take issue with it - and I think I agree. I did have a reason for the mid-sentence start, but I think I’m abandoning that original idea.
                like

                People who have liked this comment on a chapter of <i>Oak and Stone: A Book of Enai</i>

                  Robert Batten followed Sam Fellows
                  Sam Fellows
                  London-based aspiring writer of fantasy epics for grown-ups in the style of Robert Jordan and Steven...
                  Follow
                  Heidi Rebstock followed Sam Fellows
                  Sam Fellows
                  London-based aspiring writer of fantasy epics for grown-ups in the style of Robert Jordan and Steven...
                  Follow
                  More items