James Rasile liked the forum thread, Be careful if you accept an offer from a collective!

I think it’s a good general rule not to join any collective that doesn’t have a proven audience to market to.  Take the time to form good relationships with other authors in the community here (and outside of it), and you will get equal or more powerful support, for free, from people who will promote you because they like your work and want to see you succeed. No royalties needed.

And it’s worth pointing out that we’re still in the initial phases of seeing if the "professional" collections (Nerdist, S&L, Geek & Sundry) provide services and marketing that are worth the percentage their collections take. The idea works in theory, and there maybe be initial examples of clear benefits for certain books, but every book is different and there is no guarantee of success for any book. The author still has to do a TON of work, collection or not.

In the interests of getting a slightly clearer impression on the effect of being chosen for each of these collections, I did some research! There are too few books for any sort of statistical analysis to be meaningful, but we can still use this data to help us make informed decisions.

The first contest, for the Sword & Laser collection, started April 1st, 2015. The contest winners’ books came out mostly in a batch in the spring of 2016 (Lost Generation is still in production and will be excellent, I’m certain). I don’t know how many copies of these books were sold pre-release; I’m just going with sales as of today (remember that some of these books have been out longer than others, so that may have an effect on sales numbers). S&L takes 10% of your royalties, and it is unclear whether that is 10% of your new cut under the new royalty structure or 10% of gross receipts.

Contest winner + chosen for the collection:
An Unattractive Vampire - 2,538
Asteroid Made of Dragons - 2,063
The Life Engineered - 1,977
Average: 2,192

Contest winner + not chosen:
Practical Applications of Multiverse Theory - 1,440
Ageless: 1,316
Average: 1,378

There aren’t any other books out for the S&L Collection yet, though there are three in production – two of those were chosen for the collection and are not contest winners, so perhaps we’ll see a difference there. (One is written by a host of the podcast, Tom Merritt, so obviously there’s a connection to the audience there that the other authors in the collection don’t start with.)

The first Nerdist contest started August 15th, 2015. Only two books from the winning group have been released (both this month), but a few more will be released very soon. I did an average of the next two books to be released because that’s the best I have. Nerdist takes 20% of gross receipts, according to the collection specifications; these specifications still say the author gets 30% of gross receipts as well, which is a better cut than the new royalty structure. (I will be interested to see if Inkshares re-negotiates that deal with Nerdist to make it match the new structure or not.)

 Contest winner + chosen for the collection:
Welcome to Deadland - 4,813
It’s All Fun and Games – 1,633
Average: 3,223

Contest winner + not chosen (being released soon, numbers will surely jump):
Rise – 1,760
7th Age: Dawn – 1,108

Average: 1,434

 

I’m sure you can pick out the outlier – Welcome to Deadland is doing really, really well. With so few books out, it’s difficult to tell if there’s a significant difference between how any given book performs based on any single characteristic. We’ll see what happens as more books come out!

(It’s important to note that there is one book that was selected for the Nerdist collection which didn’t win a contest, and has 17 pre-orders. Being chosen for a collection doesn’t guarantee any number of orders.)

It certainly looks like being chosen for a collection when you win a contest will increase your orders by more than their cut of your royalties. It will be interesting to see what happens when the first book chosen for the S&L Collection outside of winning a contest, Deus Hex Machina, does when it is released. I suspect winning a contest provides its own bump in orders, on top of the benefits of full publishing compared to Quill publishing-level services.

You have to take into consideration whether a given collection is a good fit for your book before you commit to giving them part of your royalties. For some people it will be a no-brainer; for others, it might not be. Do what’s best for your book, based on everything that’s possible to take into account!

like · liked by James

People who have liked this comment in the forum thread, Be careful if you accept an offer from a collective!

    James Rasile followed Katherine A Napier
    Katherine A Napier
    An avid reader. Poet.
    Follow
    Andres Garcia followed James Rasile
    James Rasile
    Author of Cape’s Side Bay, and my own personal letters to Santa Claus.
    Follow
    James Rasile liked an update for Sadie McGrady Runs for President

    SADIE FANS: Today, Inkshares e-mailed each of you a download link for a sneak peek at the Sadie McGrady Runs for President eBook. It’s a little thank you for your early support of the book, helping us reach publication. After you read it, please link to this GOODREADS PAGE and help us generate some early ratings/reviews! 

    Hardcover copies of Sadie McGrady Runs for President are coming your way in September. Once we reach the official publication date, October 4, 2016, we’ll be asking you to (pretty please) offer another review on Amazon.com. This will help Sadie reach more next generation leaders. 

    Enjoy your eBook copy and thanks again for your awesome support!

    Mary & Corey

    like · liked by Heidi, and 1 other

    People who have liked this reader update

      jacob browning followed James Rasile
      James Rasile
      Author of Cape’s Side Bay, and my own personal letters to Santa Claus.
      Follow
      James Rasile liked a chapter from Through The Ghost

      The hot sun permeated Anna’s light brown armor in the dry, oven like heat. Her dirty-blonde hair was pulled into a short pony tail. Sweat trickled into her emerald green eyes as she tried to look down the scope of her rifle. A bland set of buildings, surrounded by high walls with a single entrance loomed beneath her. High on her perch 3000 meters away, she overlooked the small compound from the side of the eastern mountain range. Officially, she had been banned from pursuing this lead. Even if. . .

      Continue Reading
      recommend · recommended by Candice and 2 others

      People who have recommended the chapter, Avenger of Azariah

        James Rasile liked a chapter from Through The Ghost

        The hot sun permeated Anna’s light brown armor in the dry, oven like heat. Her dirty-blonde hair was pulled into a short pony tail. Sweat trickled into her emerald green eyes as she tried to look down the scope of her rifle. A bland set of buildings, surrounded by high walls with a single entrance loomed beneath her. High on her perch 3000 meters away, she overlooked the small compound from the side of the eastern mountain range. Officially, she had been banned from pursuing this lead. Even if. . .

        Continue Reading
        recommend · recommended by Candice and 2 others

        People who have recommended the chapter, Avenger of Azariah

          James Rasile liked an update for The Zookeeper’s Dilemma

          It’s the Monday Update, so here’s the latest part of The Zookeeper’s Dilemma. After next week, that will be the first three chapters up and about a third of the book, so I won’t be posting any more from the book. You’ll just have to buy a copy to see what happens next. I’ll also link to e-reader friendly version of all the sample chapters for those of you who don’t like reading books on the computer.

          I know I hinted there might be a short story going up, but when I started working on it, I realized it was a much better fit with my other Inkshares project, The Problem with Prophecy which I will be re-releasing for pre-orders later this year. Please check it out and follow if you like. I’ll try to have something a different story up soon, but I’ll have to write it first. So much to do, so little time.

          Also, watch for Unlikely & Other Stories, Book 2 of my serialized superhero series, to be released into the wild this fall. You can find Book 1, Unremarkable & Other Stories, available for free download via the links here. That’s all for now. Hopefully there will be more good news soon.

          like · liked by James

          People who have liked this reader update

            James Rasile liked an update for Deus Hex Machina

            Today is a big day, one that I have been dreading and anticipating in equal measure. Today, I officially start editing Deus Hex Machina and building my second draft.

            Here’s what the process looks like. Staples is now my spirit animal: 

            For the next 30 days it’s my plan to implement the changes I have noted down on those little blue cards, honing my first draft into a stronger, more coherent second. When that is done, I will be more than ready to move from alpha reading into beta. As before, let me know if you’re interested.

            Once I have the second draft returned from beta readers I’ll hash out a third draft, and then I should be ready to submit to Inkshares by the end of the year. For those that like timelines (and so that I have some accountability for my process) here is what I have planned for the next year:



            Like any plan, this will probably change around a bit. Generally though, I am planning to write two books a year, and fund one novel in each series. This doesn’t include other projects I want to be part of, collaborations like Too Many Controllers and Makhaira, so my schedule is going to need to be a little fluid should something awesome come up that I want to take part in. I’m also toying with the idea of funding Shadow of the Owl again before I  fund the sequel. There is just something very appealing about having the entire series under the Inkshares publishing umbrella. 

            Speaking of series, for those of you curious minded folks out there, Deus Hex Machina is a trilogy, and Shadow of the Owl et al is a series with six books planned.
            So if you look at that calendar, you’ll be able to extrapolate out and figure out what I have planned for the year after that. 


            TL;DR: Lots of writing will be happening, mostly in my two main series so if you’re eager to find out what happens to Mylena or Isidore, fear not, books are coming.

             If you have any questions, comment here or hit me up on Twitter @amandaorneck.

            Enjoy the silence!
            like · liked by Erin and 16 others

            People who have liked this reader update

              James Rasile liked a chapter from The Spark Internal

              Cyael strode down the dark corridor, his boot footfalls breaking the still silence. Magical torches sparking to life as he passed, their dim blue light shimmering across his armor. If any were around he would seem to be an apparition haunting the ancient halls. Cyael’s eyes fixed on the door at the end of the hall lost in the thoughts that had lead him here. He had come down this path before over the centuries, but rarely this late and never alone, yet did so tonight with grim determination. S. . .

              Continue Reading
              recommend · recommended by Ben and 3 others

              People who have recommended the chapter, Prologue

                More items