Heidi Rebstock commented on an excerpt of Frost: An Otherworld Tale
You accidentally added two commas here. Also, the "in reality" part seems unnecessary. I’d get rid of it.
like

People who have liked this comment on a chapter of <i>Frost: An Otherworld Tale</i>

    Heidi Rebstock highlighted an excerpt from Frost: An Otherworld Tale
    The door creaked open,, and my mom squinted at me in sleepy confusion until she realized that I was, in reality, shivering on her doorstep.
    Read Chapter
    Heidi Rebstock commented on an excerpt of Frost: An Otherworld Tale
    Great opening line! It caught my attention right away!
    like

    People who have liked this comment on a chapter of <i>Frost: An Otherworld Tale</i>

      Heidi Rebstock highlighted an excerpt from Frost: An Otherworld Tale
      My breath froze in my chest as I bolted from the safety of the warm cab into a rainy English night.
      Read Chapter
      Heidi Rebstock created a forum thread: Give Feedback, Get Feedback
      I’m very new here, and this is my first foray into trying to get a book published (it’s also my first writing contest!). I’d really like to get some feedback on the first chapter to see if its powerful enough to draw readers in (I don’t feel like it is, sadly.)
      Join the discussion