It’s a strange time to be an author. While it hasn’t gotten any easier to get into a major publishing house, the simplicity of self-publishing is made more and more tempting with each rejection letter. All a writer needs to do now is throw some words together in a file, submit said file to KDP or one of the other enumerable self-pub houses, and PRESTO: a book is born. That eliminates an author’s need for an editor, a marketer, and any of the prestige of actually being published. Why would one need to share their royalties with anyone, if one is able to just do everything for themselves? Why go through the heartbreaking process of submitting and getting rejected dozens of times when one is able to simply upload the file, magically creating a masterpiece with no restrictions? Does an author truly need to do revisions if they’ve said everything they want to in their first draft, and a self-publisher will release it without any question? It’s an enticing offer, no doubt. Should one simply want to say that they’re an author, not caring about sales or the future of their project, it’s possibly one that should be capitalized on.
It’s also cheating, and it robs the hypothetical author of the true publishing experience. As any author will tell you, the process of writing a successful book is only about 30% writing. There’s the submission/rejection process, which we’re not supposed to take personally, but each rejection still chips away at the writer’s soul. Once that acceptance letter does finally arrive, there’s the knock-down-drag-out battle that the author will inevitably have with their editor, who will likely become a trusted friend, if the two are able to keep themselves from killing each other. There’s the formatting combat, which involves arguing about the font size, the word count, the cover picture, and countless other factors, and that’s all before the book even hits the market. Once it hits the market, there’s a whole different set of complications. However, once it’s on the market, there’s another property that makes all of the suffering they’ve gone through worthwhile: they’ve published a book. Not only has their book been published, but people who aren’t just family and friends believe in them, and they want them to succeed. They have fans and readers who want to know when their next book is being released. Bookstores will want them to come in and talk to their customers, coffee shops will fill up with people who want to talk about their work, and opportunities will come. Once a publisher releases a book, it’s in their best interest that the book sell, and they’ll do whatever they can to make sure that happens. This is what an author wants.
I’m not suggesting that self-publishing is bad. I have a few short stories on Amazon that I released through KDP. I’m simply suggesting that, by submitting to self-publishing, a writer does their craft a disservice. You’ve worked long and hard on your piece of art. Doesn’t it deserve to be treated with respect?