DR, you caught me with your title, two of my favorite subjects Italy and Wine not to mention a mystery. Its funny writing to make suggestions to an author if you have never written a book yourself, but I have read plenty and I favor mysteries. As another reader commented, it is a little hard to identify with a character when you do not know their name nor have clues about their appearance. When I read I am making a movie in my head as I go along I try and visualize what I am reading. Perhaps other do not do this but for the visual readers you may want to give them some of the external Sofi too, we get to learn a lot about her inner life but she does not take shape as a physical being in the first chapter.
So you are not a total outsider. Also explain why an Italian American get out into the world alive without learning the basics of spaghetti sauce and seasonings? I’m not Italina and I’ve learned to make a decent sauce from scratch even though Paul Newman’s sauces can save a gal from doom at a dinner party.
Again why not feel as if you belong. Does the main character not know of her ancestral beginnings? Hmm the characters parents are woeful in their ability to prepare the main character for life in the glorious country of Italia!
The character whose name you have failed to give your readers is woefully uneducated about the importance of Italian wine in the Global economy.